What observers say
“The United States is the American dream, that’s what they call it. But no, it wasn’t like that,” reflects J, a Venezuelan immigrant whose life was upended when federal agents took his wife in February 2026. His statement encapsulates the disillusionment felt by many in Baldwin, Wisconsin, as the town grapples with the ramifications of recent deportation actions.
In a community that is over 95% white and leans Republican, Baldwin has seen its immigrant population grow in recent years. However, this demographic shift has not come without tension. More than 50 individuals were taken by federal agents during a series of raids that peaked in January and February 2026. These actions have left residents feeling unsafe and have prompted the formation of mutual aid networks to support families affected by deportations.
Local business owner Jairo Sarango, who runs EcuaMarket, has experienced a steep decline in customers, as many residents feel uncomfortable leaving their homes amid the heightened enforcement. “I really think that they came into small towns thinking there would be no resistance,” says Julie N, a local activist. Her words reflect a growing sentiment among residents who are beginning to organize against what they perceive as aggressive immigration enforcement tactics.
At a recent village board meeting, four residents spoke out against ICE, questioning the involvement of local police in immigration enforcement. This has sparked a broader conversation about community safety and the role of law enforcement in immigration matters. As Denise Flaherty, a concerned resident, stated, “This is a super important fight. I care very deeply about what happens in Baldwin and what kind of community I’m part of.” Such statements highlight the emotional toll these deportations are taking on the community.
The Trump administration had promised mass deportations, yet the actual number of deportations carried out by ICE has not been regularly disclosed to the public. As of July 2024, ICE had identified 435,000 unauthorized immigrants with criminal convictions in the United States who were not in custody. By the end of May 2025, ICE had arrested 752 non-citizens convicted of murder and 1,693 convicted of sexual assault, raising questions about the prioritization of enforcement actions.
Despite the federal government’s assurances, many residents in Baldwin are left questioning the safety of their community. A spokesperson for the Department of Homeland Security remarked, “Every day, DHS enforces the laws of the nation across the country including in Minnesota and Wisconsin to keep Americans safe.” However, the reality on the ground tells a different story, as families are torn apart and local businesses suffer.
Details remain unconfirmed regarding the specific reasons Baldwin was targeted by immigration enforcement agents. The uncertainty surrounding the deportation actions has only added to the anxiety felt by residents, both immigrant and native alike. As the community continues to navigate this crisis, the future of Baldwin hangs in the balance, with many hoping for a resolution that respects both the rule of law and the dignity of its residents.
