Why was Hannah Hidalgo, a standout guard for the Notre Dame Fighting Irish, not selected as a finalist for the Naismith Award despite an extraordinary season? The answer lies in the complexities of recognition in collegiate sports, where performance metrics do not always translate to accolades.
During the 2025-2026 season, Hidalgo averaged an impressive 25.2 points, 6.7 rebounds, 5.2 assists, and 5.6 steals per game. Her statistics alone would suggest she is a top contender for any award, yet she was overlooked.
Hidalgo’s recent performance in the NCAA tournament further solidified her status as a rising star. In a pivotal March Madness game against Vanderbilt, she recorded a triple-double with 31 points, 11 rebounds, and 10 steals. This achievement not only helped Notre Dame secure a 67-64 victory but also marked her as the second player in NCAA tournament history to achieve a triple-double with steals.
Moreover, Hidalgo broke the NCAA single-season steals record with a staggering 199 steals, and her ten steals in the game against Vanderbilt set a new NCAA tournament record for total steals in one tournament, totaling 26.
Despite these accomplishments, Hidalgo’s exclusion from the Naismith Award finalists has raised eyebrows among fans and analysts alike. “Hannah is the player of the year,” said teammate KK Bransford, highlighting the disconnect between her performance and the recognition she has received.
Hidalgo’s journey has not been without challenges. Notre Dame started the season with a 13-8 record, eventually earning a No. 6 seed in the NCAA tournament. Her leadership and skill have been pivotal in turning the team’s fortunes around, leading them to the Elite Eight for the first time since 2019.
As she prepares to face top-seeded UConn for a spot in the Final Four, questions linger about the criteria used for player recognition in collegiate basketball. “What are you going to do to get over this hump?” asked Charel Allen, emphasizing the need for Hidalgo to continue proving herself on the court.
Hidalgo’s performance has not only garnered attention for her skills but also for her ability to inspire. After speaking with Maya Moore at the Final Four, she is keenly aware of what it takes to win a championship.
As the tournament progresses, it remains to be seen how Hidalgo’s story will unfold. Will she finally receive the recognition she deserves, or will her remarkable achievements continue to go unnoticed? Details remain unconfirmed.
